A Caltech Library Service

Self-gravity, self-consistency, and self-organization in geodynamics and geochemistry

Anderson, Don L. (2005) Self-gravity, self-consistency, and self-organization in geodynamics and geochemistry. In: Earth's Deep Mantle: Structure, Composition, and Evolution. Geophysical Monograph Series. No.160. American Geophysical Union , Washington, DC , pp. 165-186. ISBN 0-87590-425-4.

PDF - Published Version
See Usage Policy.


Use this Persistent URL to link to this item:


The results of seismology and geochemistry for mantle structure are widely believed to be discordant, the former favoring whole-mantle convection and the latter favoring layered convection with a boundary near 650 km. However, a different view arises from recognizing effects usually ignored in the construction of these models, including physical plausibility and dimensionality. Self-compression and expansion affect material properties that are important in all aspects of mantle geochemistry and dynamics, including the interpretation of tomographic images. Pressure compresses a solid and changes physical properties that depend on volume and does so in a highly nonlinear way. Intrinsic, anelastic, compositional, and crystal structure effects control seismic velocities; temperature is not the only parameter, even though tomographic images are often treated as temperature maps. Shear velocity is not a good proxy for density, temperature, and composition or for other elastic constants. Scaling concepts are important in mantle dynamics, equations of state, and wherever it is necessary to extend laboratory experiments to the parameter range of the Earth's mantle. Simple volume-scaling relations that permit extrapolation of laboratory experiments, in a thermodynamically self-consistent way, to deep mantle conditions include the quasiharmonic approximation but not the Boussinesq formalisms. Whereas slabs, plates, and the upper thermal boundary layer of the mantle have characteristic thicknesses of hundreds of kilometers and lifetimes on the order of 100 million years, volume-scaling predicts values an order of magnitude higher for deep-mantle thermal boundary layers. This implies that deep-mantle features are sluggish and ancient. Irreversible chemical stratification is consistent with these results; plausible temperature variations in the deep mantle cause density variations that are smaller than the probable density contrasts across chemical interfaces created by accretional differentiation and magmatic processes. Deep-mantle features may be convectively isolated from upper-mantle processes. Plate tectonics and surface geochemical cycles appear to be entirely restricted to the upper ~1,000 km. The 650-km discontinuity is mainly an isochemical phase change but major-element chemical boundaries may occur at other depths. Recycling laminates the upper mantle and also makes it statistically heterogeneous, in agreement with high-frequency scattering studies. In contrast to standard geochemical models and recent modifications, the deeper layers need not be accessible to surface volcanoes. There is no conflict between geophysical and geochemical data, but a physical basis for standard geochemical and geodynamic mantle models, including the two-layer and whole-mantle versions, and qualitative tomographic interpretations has been lacking.

Item Type:Book Section
Additional Information:© 2005 American Geophysical Union. I thank Adrian Lenardic, Russell Hemley, Jun Korenaga, and Anne Hofmeister for incisive reviews of an early draft and Raymond Jeanloz for discussions of related points. Frank Stacey, Geoffry Davies, Shijie Zhong, Robert Liebermann, and Yaoling Niu gave important advice for improvement and in correcting mistakes. Scott King's comments on the penultimate and ultimate versions were invaluable. Gillian Foulger, Seth Stein, Anders Meibom, Kanani Lee, and Jeroen Ritsema reviewed, and provided valuable input for, the revised version. Conversations with David Stevenson, Rob van der Hilst, Jeroen Ritsema, Jeroen Tromp, Bradford Hager, Richard O'Connell, Thomas Duffy, and Thorne Lay helped me identify problems and consolidate ideas, but mistakes and oversights, of course, are mine.
Record Number:CaltechAUTHORS:20110513-135907345
Persistent URL:
Usage Policy:No commercial reproduction, distribution, display or performance rights in this work are provided.
ID Code:23667
Deposited By: Ruth Sustaita
Deposited On:17 May 2011 15:52
Last Modified:26 Dec 2012 13:14

Repository Staff Only: item control page