Jacobsen, Stein B. and Wasserburg, G. J.
(1979)
The Mean Age of Mantle and Crustal Reservoirs.
Journal of Geophysical Research B, 84
(B13).
pp. 74117427.
ISSN 01480227.
https://resolver.caltech.edu/CaltechAUTHORS:20131120153025570
Preview 

PDF
 Published Version
See Usage Policy.
1299Kb 
Use this Persistent URL to link to this item: https://resolver.caltech.edu/CaltechAUTHORS:20131120153025570
Abstract
Mantle and crust evolution is discussed in terms of two simple transport models. In model I, continents (j = 3) are derived by melt extraction over the history of the earth from undepleted mantle (j = 1), and the residue forms a depleted mantle (j = 2), which today is the source of midocean ridge basalts. In model II, new additions to continents are derived from a mantle reservoir 2, which becomes more depleted through time by repeated extraction of melts. Transport equations were solved for stable s, radioactive r, and daughter d isotopes for arbitrary mass growth curves M_j(τ). For both models the isotopic composition and concentrations of trace elements are shown to reduce to simple mathematical expressions which readily permit calculations of basic evolutionary parameters from the data. For longlived isotopes (λ^(−1) ≫ 4.5 aeons) for model I the deviations in parts in 10^4 of the ratio of a daughter isotope to a stable reference isotope of the same element in reservoirs j = 2, 3 from that of 1 is given by E_(dj)^*=Q_d^*t_(Mj)ƒ_j^(r/s). Here t_(Mj) is the mean age of the mass of j,ƒ_j^(r/s) is the enrichment factor of the ratio of a radioactive isotope to a stable isotope relative to that in 1, and Q_d^* ≃ const. Thus for longlived isotopes such as ^(147)Sm and ^(87)Rb the only time information that can be obtained from model I from measurement of the relative chemical enrichment factors and isotopic ratios at a single time is the mean age of the mass of the continental crust and the complementary depleted mantle reservoir. This mean age is independent of the longlived parentdaughter system. An analogous result is obtained for model II, where E_(d.2)^*= Q_d^*(ƒ_2^(r/s))t. Here (ƒ_2^(r/s)) is the weighted time average of the enrichment factor, and τ is the time measured from the origin of the earth. The mean age of the mass of the crust (t_(M.3)) and the time parameter t_(r/s)=t(ƒ_2^(r/s))/ƒ_2^(r/s) for the crust in model II will for longlived parentdaughter systems be different depending on the element fractionation during partial melting. Decay systems with small parentdaughter fractionations during partial melting may, however, be used to estimate the mean age of the continental crust. SmNd and RbSr isotopic data for continental crust, depleted and undepleted mantle, have been used to evaluate both models and yield young mean ages for the mass of the continental crust of 1.8 and 1.5 aeons for model I and model II, respectively. Both models also suggest that the rate of growth of the continents for the last 0.5 aeon is much less than the average growth rate. The young mean age of the continents implies either rapid refluxing of crustal materials to the mantle in the period from 4.5 to 3.6 aeons or that very little early crust ever formed. Mass balance calculations for both models show that the continents were only formed from ∼30% of the total mantle, leaving 70% of the mantle as undepleted. The major difference in the two models lies in the difference in the compositions of newly derived crust. For model I the trace element concentrations in new additions to the crust is constant, and the isotopic values are those of the undepleted mantle reservoir, in agreement with recent Nd isotopic studies. The correlation line between ε_(Nd) and ε_(Sr) for young basalts can be explained with model I by mixing depleted and undepleted mantle, but it cannot in any simple way be explained by model II. Model II implies that new additions to the continents have the isotopic characteristics of depleted mantle and that the concentration of Rb, U, Ba, and other highly incompatible trace elements in newly added material have changed by a factor of ∼10 through time, for which there is no evidence. For both models the simple analytical expressions derived herein permit calculations of earth models with great facility without requiring a computer calculation.
Item Type:  Article 

Related URLs:  

ORCID:  

Additional Information:  © 1979 American Geophysical Union. Received May 22, 1979;
accepted August 14, 1979. This work has been supported by NSF grant EAR 7622494 and NASA grant NGL 05002188. We wish to thank R. J. O'Connell for his thorough and scholarly analysis of the manuscript, which resulted in several substantial improvements. Supporting and critical discussions with our colleagues M. McCulloch and R.
Jeanloz were of great value. We thank the editor, T. J. Ahrens, and the associate editor, J. Hayes, for careful attention to the manuscript and the reviewers, M. J. Drake and G. Wetherill, for their attention to what might be viewed as a difficult manuscript. G. Wetherill pointed
out to us that the earth probably looks more like a $10 ice cream sundae than an oil refinery with discrete storage tanks. We hope some day to share the $10 ice cream sundae with him. Contribution #3251 (306). 

Funders:  Funding Agency  Grant Number 

NSF  EAR 7622494  NASA  NGL 05002188 


Other Numbering System:  Other Numbering System Name  Other Numbering System ID 

Caltech Division of Geological and Planetary Sciences  3251  Lunatic Asylum Lab  306 


Issue or Number:  B13 

Record Number:  CaltechAUTHORS:20131120153025570 

Persistent URL:  https://resolver.caltech.edu/CaltechAUTHORS:20131120153025570 

Official Citation:  Jacobsen, S. B., and G. J. Wasserburg (1979), The mean age of mantle and crustal reservoirs, J. Geophys. Res., 84(B13), 7411–7427, doi:10.1029/JB084iB13p07411 

Usage Policy:  No commercial reproduction, distribution, display or performance rights in this work are provided. 

ID Code:  42602 

Collection:  CaltechAUTHORS 

Deposited By: 
Ruth Sustaita


Deposited On:  21 Nov 2013 16:33 

Last Modified:  09 Mar 2020 13:19 

Repository Staff Only: item control page