Does Symmetry Drive Isotopic Anomalies in Ozone Isotopomer Formation? - Response

Abstract

Gao and Marcus presented a modified Rice, Ramsperger, Kassel, Marcus (RRKM)–based theory to explain the strange and unconventional ozone isotope effect that has puzzled scientists for years. In earlier studies, mass spectrometric and diode laser measurements of ozone isotopomers in “scrambled” oxygen mixtures pointed toward a symmetry origin for isotope fractionation. Kinetic studies, however, contradicted the dominant role of symmetry, and later experiments revealed an unconventional mass dependency, in which isotopomer formation correlates with the enthalpy of the competing isotopic exchange. Marcus and co-workers have offered a solution to this puzzle by imposing two different fractionation factors. The first was incorporated into the theory as an ad hoc factor to describe possible nonstatistical effects, which affect asymmetric and symmetric molecule formation differently. The second, which can be called zero-point energy fractionation (ZPEF), can be treated within the RRKM theory and relates to competing properties of the exit channel transition states.