Transitive permutation groups and equipotent voting rules

Abstract

Let F a two-alternative voting rule and G_F the subgroup of permutations of the voters under which F is invariant. Group theoretic properties of G_F provide information about the voting rule F. In particular, sets of imprimitivity of G_F describe the ‘committee decomposition’ structure of F and permutation group transitivity of G_F (equipotency) is shown to be closely connected with equal distribution of power among the voters. If equipotency replaces anonymity in the hypotheses of May's theorem, voting rules other than simple majority are possible. By combining equipotency with two additional social choice conditions a new characterization of simple majority rule is obtained. Equipotency is proposed as an important alternative to the more restrictive anonymity as a fairness criterion in social choice.